§5.5 Coda: Engineering the Factory
Process design and tolerance help explain the different arrangements observed in this chapter (Figure 5.1-1). DocAble's accessibility obligations and one-engineer staffing made explicit requirements and automated rejection especially valuable: I had little inherited human process to accommodate and no spare reviewers for every implementation decision. Coordinating agents still required work orders, scheduling, and completion checks. In an established organization, the factory must also fit existing teams, knowledge, and authority. Both settings require judgments about which properties to preserve and how to organize work around them. A more capable agent may change the process needed to produce a system without changing its memory bound or deployment restriction. Engineers can leave implementation choices open within those bounds, while weighing the cost of supervision against the cost of maintaining the representations and checks that support it.
Organizations need not begin with fully autonomous implementation. Some use agents to review pull requests or propose changes that people still inspect. Others allow agents to implement and validate changes before routing selected decisions to human reviewers. These arrangements delegate different amounts of work and authority, but they face the same engineering questions: what must remain true, what evidence establishes it, and which decisions require human approval? MAGE applies to those questions even when most implementation remains under direct human supervision.
Capability also does not settle accountability. Organizations delegate consequential judgment to people partly through incentives and responsibility, including professional obligations and institutional consequences 1.1. James G. March and Herbert A. Simon, Organizations (Wiley, 1958). An agent does not bear those responsibilities or respond to those incentives in the same way a human engineer does. Its instructions and permissions can be changed, and its work can be stopped, but those actions do not transfer human accountability to it. Engineering authority must therefore decide which judgments to delegate, what evidence to require, and which obligations need controls. Chapter 6 examines the costs and effects of these choices: how representation and independent evaluation change the economics of realization, and how experience changes the engineering structures worth maintaining.
Works Cited
- March, James G., and Herbert A. Simon. Organizations. Wiley, 1958.